Deferred Commencement In NSW: The Consent That Has Not Started Yet

APPROVED ON PAPER, BUT NOT OPERATING YET?NSW: check deferred-commencement conditions before relying on consent.

There is a type of development consent in New South Wales that is granted without starting. It exists on paper, it satisfies a bank's requirement for an approval, and it can still lapse without a single cubic metre of work ever being done — because the consent does not operate until the applicant satisfies council on particular matters.

The deal question: is this consent actually switched on?

The NSW Department of Planning, Housing and Infrastructure guide to writing conditions of consent sets the framework. A deferred commencement condition, imposed under section 4.16(3) of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979, requires certain matters to be satisfied before the consent can operate. Only the consent authority can assess whether a matter has been satisfied, and it must notify the applicant of the date from which the consent operates.

Read that carefully and the consequence is uncomfortable: the day the consent was determined is not necessarily the day it began. The clock the developer usually watches — the lapsing period for physical commencement — is not running yet.

Effective is not the same as operative

The consent exists, and you are permitted to do what is necessary to satisfy the condition. What you cannot do is rely on it as an operating approval for the development. Dentons' analysis of physical commencement puts it plainly: a consent is not operative until the deferred commencement conditions have been satisfied; the consent lapses if the condition is not satisfied within the period specified; and the time for physically commencing the consent to prevent it lapsing does not run until the consent becomes operative.

For a student, the practical translation is this. If you are buying a site with an existing consent, you cannot assume there is a five-year runway ahead of you. There may instead be a condition with its own deadline that has been quietly running down since the consent was granted.

What a deferred commencement condition looks like in practice

The Department's guide gives a usable example: securing a right of carriageway to give access to a site that does not have a direct frontage to a road. The consent authority still has to consider the likely environmental impacts of the proposal, including those associated with the right of carriageway, before granting consent, and confirm in-principle agreement from the affected adjoining owner. The consent then does not operate until the applicant has obtained the right of carriageway and provided evidence of that to the council's satisfaction.

Notice what kind of matter that is. It is external to the site, it depends on a third party's agreement, and it is essential to the development working at all. Those are the classic deferred commencement subjects: access, easements, landowner agreements, sometimes a separate approval that must be in place first.

The limit the courts have drawn

Deferral is not a way to postpone the hard questions. The Department's guide records the caution from a 2020 case, Ballina Shire Council v Palm Lake Works Pty Ltd [2020] NSWLEC 41, where a consent was challenged because a deferred commencement condition effectively deferred a complete assessment of civil works in a road reserve. The guide states that a deferred commencement condition should not defer consideration of a critical component of the development assessment process, and that failing to consider a likely impact before consent is granted can result in the consent being declared invalid.

That is a reminder that a deferred commencement consent is not a weak approval to be treated with suspicion so much as a conditional one to be read precisely. The matters to be satisfied should be certain in outcome and critical to the consent operating — and nothing more.

How you actually switch it on

The mechanical steps are documented by councils. Byron Shire Council's deferred commencement page describes the sequence: meet the deferred commencement conditions (which may require submitting more information, another application or certificate, or having a report prepared); request an operational consent on the development application through the NSW Planning Portal with the supporting documents; and await council's review. Once council is satisfied, you receive operational consent notification and the consent is operational. Until then, the page states plainly, you cannot undertake any other work or action.

Two details matter for planning. First, the evidence you attach has to be the evidence council asked for — if the condition names a certificate, an informal email will not discharge it. Second, this is a second administrative gate after determination, and it takes its own time. Build that into your programme rather than discovering it the week you intend to start.

The checks a capable student would run

• Read the consent for the words. Look for "deferred commencement" or a reference to section 4.16(3), and separate the conditions that must be satisfied before the consent operates from every other condition.
• Find the date the consent operates from. Confirm whether the consent authority has notified the applicant of the date from which the consent operates, or whether that has not yet happened.
• Identify every third party involved. Access agreements, easements and adjoining-owner consents all depend on someone else's decision, so they carry the longest lead times.
• Check the specified period. The consent may specify a shorter period than the general maximum for producing the evidence; treat the shorter period as the deadline.
• Price the cost of satisfying the condition into your feasibility. A right of carriageway or an easement may involve legal costs, compensation or a land transfer, and it should be in the numbers before you exchange.

The trap: buying a consent that never switched on

The quiet failure on a site purchase is assuming an approval is an approval. A deferred commencement consent with an unsatisfied condition looks identical, in a contract and in a bank's file, to an operative one. The problem surfaces when you apply for a construction certificate, or when you try to act on the consent, and find that no consent is currently in operation — by which point the money is committed and the site is yours.

What you do not have to work out alone

You are not expected to interpret the conditions or handle council's assessment yourself. A property lawyer reads the consent and confirms which conditions must be satisfied before it operates and what evidence will discharge them; a town planner can identify the planning pathway where a condition requires a separate approval; and where the condition depends on access, easements or adjoining land, your solicitor manages the third-party arrangement. Your job is to find out, before you commit, whether the consent you are paying for is actually running.

Learn with Jason & AmyBuild practical small-scale property development skills with experienced mentors.Enquire now

Photo: 'Semi-detached house in Crampton Street, Wagga Wagga' by Bidgee, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0 AU.